The Deontic Gap: Large Language Models and the Modal Language of Obligation

arXiv:2608.181442026-08-20

Modal auxiliaries such as must, should, and have to mark necessity and obligation within the contexts of speaker authority and interpersonal stance. We examine whether large language models (LLMs) reproduce contemporary human patterns of deontic modal usage. Across three primary corpora, an external benchmark, two controlled replications, and a naturalistic eleven-model replication, AI-generated text consistently underuses positive deontic modals (

Authors · Daniel Hart, Sarah Allred, Joseph Abbas, Morenike Alugo