MerchantBench: Benchmarking LLM Agents for Long-Term Coherence in E-Commerce Operations

arXiv:2607.289562026-07-30

让LLM智能体经营365天网店,结果大多数比人类更快就撒手不管了

MerchantBench是一个基于98,843条真实电商商品数据构建的365天模拟网店环境,用来测试LLM智能体能否在长期持续运营中保持连贯合理的判断。研究让8个LLM在两种智能体框架下各跑三次,共48次365天模拟,考察商品选品、定价、现金流和延迟反馈应对能力。即便表现最好的LLM配置,最终净资产也只达到人类参与者平均水平的27.3%。

METAL LAB 解读图

MerchantBench如何用模拟一年来考验智能体的持久力

证据状态已报告实测结果

真实数据商品目录来自1688平台的98,843条真实商品记录与36,576家供应商数据,每条记录附带365天需求历史,被移植进模拟环境
四项持续性决策商品选品、上架与定价管理、现金流管理、应对不同延迟的反馈,均通过26种工具完成
快信号与慢信号供应商事件(涨价、缺货)很快可见,而订单结果(退货、退款、差评)延迟显现,逐渐侵蚀现金和店铺评分
48次评测运行8个LLM x 2种框架(ReAct、Hermes)x 3次重复,共48次365天模拟,并与3名人类参与者及规则型机器人对比
连贯性丧失诊断通过决策轨迹记录揭示运营连贯性丧失(活动逐渐减少)与策略连贯性丧失(目标漂移)两种失败模式

这是 METAL LAB 制作的解读图，并非论文作者提供的原图。

他们做了什么

以往的智能体评测大多是有明确成败标准的短任务,这项研究关注的是长期连贯性(Long-Term Coherence),即能否在漫长过程中持续追求目标并根据累积证据调整决策。
环境基于1688(中国大型批发电商平台)的98,843条真实商品记录和36,576家供应商数据构建,按小时推进共8,760步(相当于365天),智能体可使用26种店铺管理工具(搜索、上架、改价、查财务等)。
环境的核心设计是反馈延迟不一:新订单会立刻占用现金,但取消、退款、差评等异常结果要延后才会显现,并逐渐侵蚀店铺评分。
研究对GPT-5.6 Sol、Claude Opus 4.8、Qwen3.7-Max/Plus、GLM-5.2、DeepSeek-V4-Pro/Flash、Kimi K2.6共8个模型,分别在ReAct(仅用26种工具的最简控制器)和Hermes(附带代码执行、规划、记忆、技能管理的完整框架)下各跑三次,共48次365天模拟。
结果与三名人类参与者和一个规则型机器人对比后发现,表现最好的LLM配置最终净资产也只达到人类平均水平的27.3%,且轨迹显示出运营连贯性丧失(活动逐渐减少)和策略连贯性丧失(偏离盈利目标)两种模式。

Figure 1: Order-level dynamics couple immediate liquidity pressure with delayed feedback. New orders commit available cash before settlement, whereas abnormal outcomes surface later and affect store rating.

Table 1: Business performance, store reliability, and long-horizon activity after 365 simulated days. Values are means over three runs. Final net assets and GMV are reported in thousands of RMB, total fines in RMB, and rate metrics in percent. SWR denotes Sustained Window Rate. The best result within each framework is shown in bold.
Model or Operator	Business Performance	Store Reliability	Long-Horizon Activity
Net Assets	GMV	Profit Margin	Orders	Fines	Avg. Store Rating	Anomaly Rate	Avg. Active Listings	SWR	Tool Calls
ReAct
GPT-5.6 Sol	40.89	74.19	51.3	996	499	4.04	10.7	50.0	99.4	7,257
Claude Opus 4.8	31.89	69.10	44.4	1,214	796	4.05	12.1	24.0	45.0	1,139
Qwen3.7-Max	20.66	39.73	44.5	925	672	3.90	16.1	39.6	11.1	815
Qwen3.7-Plus	20.74	40.85	45.6	1,056	705	3.99	13.1	49.9	52.2	1,221
GLM-5.2	25.73	60.90	37.3	2,158	1,422	3.93	14.9	26.0	53.3	2,045
DeepSeek-V4-Pro	6.56	8.40	41.9	450	245	4.01	14.4	23.5	30.6	660
DeepSeek-V4-Flash	14.47	28.78	39.6	985	517	4.04	14.1	19.3	40.6	960
Kimi K2.6	24.99	63.69	32.9	2,230	1,474	3.89	15.3	47.3	10.6	1,228
Hermes
GPT-5.6 Sol	52.93	133.07	40.2	3,251	1,096	4.09	9.2	50.0	66.1	4,831
Claude Opus 4.8	35.56	83.23	39.9	1,808	1,089	4.02	11.8	22.1	31.7	1,138
Qwen3.7-Max	59.46	116.76	46.9	1,929	1,295	3.90	15.7	49.6	22.2	1,366
Qwen3.7-Plus	29.42	53.69	48.9	981	642	3.95	13.8	49.9	19.4	820
GLM-5.2	42.32	103.06	36.9	2,731	1,454	4.05	11.3	49.6	62.8	1,792
DeepSeek-V4-Pro	16.71	31.95	43.4	1,062	665	3.98	14.5	33.0	33.3	942
DeepSeek-V4-Flash	24.69	64.52	37.6	1,989	1,774	3.93	16.0	48.8	62.2	1,259
Kimi K2.6	23.96	75.06	26.8	3,398	2,671	3.73	19.1	48.3	17.8	969
Others
Human	217.61	608.06	35.3	9,442	5,622	3.98	12.5	49.1	100.0	8,311
Rule-based	24.48	53.37	40.3	1,605	1,374	3.76	18.0	50.0	100.0	3,236

Figure 2: Overview of MerchantBench. The merchant agent coordinates four decision components through shorter supplier feedback and delayed order outcomes over 365 days. The environment combines an upstream supplier simulation, a merchant store, and a downstream order level simulation to evaluate Long-Term Coherence and business outcomes.

Table 2: MerchantBench merchant tool inventory.
Tool	Access	Description
Product Sourcing
get_daily_report	Read	Returns the daily market report for the current simulation date with market news and opportunity signals
search_products	Read	Searches the visible Product Catalog using public fields
get_product_detail	Read	Returns visible product, logistics, rating, and supplier fields
get_supplier_profile	Read	Returns the public supplier profile and visible product count
list_supplier_products	Read	Lists the currently visible products from one supplier
Listing and Pricing Control
list_product	Write	Adds products to the store at specified selling prices
delist_product	Write	Removes products from the store
adjust_price	Write	Changes selling prices for active listings
review_my_listings	Read	Reviews listing age, sales velocity, fines, and fulfillment backlog
query_my_listings	Read	Returns current listings with cumulative sales, profit, and fines
query_store_performance	Read	Summarizes store outcomes by day or week
query_product_sales_stats	Read	Ranks product outcomes and reports abnormality counts
Cash-Flow Management
query_balance	Read	Returns the cash balance, security deposit, funds in transit, receivables, and fines
get_store_snapshot	Read	Summarizes orders, supply, cash, listings, and store rating
query_platform_rules	Read	Returns capital, settlement, penalty, and closure rules
query_cash_pipeline	Read	Summarizes receivable aging and active order cost exposure
Supplier and Order Monitoring
query_supply_chain_anomalies	Read	Returns new or current supplier abnormalities and affected listings
query_my_orders	Read	Searches historical orders with logistics and accounting fields
query_open_orders	Read	Returns active orders with fulfillment timing and economics
query_order_updates	Read	Returns status changes since the previous observation window
query_order_detail	Read	Returns one order’s full status timeline, accounting, and penalties
Agent Support and Control
read_memory_doc	Read	Reads the run local agent memory document
write_memory_doc	Write	Replaces the run local agent memory document
get_observation	Read	Returns the current rendered observation
list_tools	Read	Returns tool schemas after scenario filtering

Figure 3: Real-world demand patterns and calibrated risk profiles across 98,843 products. Whiskers span the 10th to 90th percentiles, and boxes show interquartile ranges.

Table 5: Built in Hermes tools provided by the official architecture.
Tool	Access	Description
Execution and Files
terminal	Execute	Executes shell commands in a persistent environment
process	Manage	Monitors and controls background processes
execute_code	Execute	Runs Python programs that call Hermes tools and process their outputs
read_file	Read	Reads text files with line numbers and pagination
write_file	Write	Creates or replaces files and checks supported formats
patch	Write	Applies targeted file edits and returns a unified diff
search_files	Read	Searches file names and contents
Memory and Skills
memory	Write	Stores durable facts that persist across sessions
session_search	Read	Searches messages from previous Hermes sessions
skills_list	Read	Lists available skills and their descriptions
skill_view	Read	Loads skill instructions and linked resources
skill_manage	Write	Creates, revises, or deletes skills
Planning and Coordination
todo	Manage	Maintains the task list for the current session
clarify	Interact	Requests clarification, feedback, or a decision from the user
delegate_task	Delegate	Assigns independent tasks to subagents
Projects and Output
project_list	Read	Lists available project workspaces
project_create	Write	Creates and activates a project workspace
project_switch	Write	Switches the active project workspace
text_to_speech	Generate	Converts text into speech audio
image_generate	Generate	Generates or edits images from prompts and references

Figure 4: Final net asset distributions across three repeated runs for each configuration.

Table 6: Built in Hermes skills and their functions.
Skill	Category	Description
apple-notes	Apple	Creates, searches, and edits Apple Notes
apple-reminders	Apple	Adds, lists, and completes Apple Reminders
findmy	Apple	Tracks Apple devices and AirTags
imessage	Apple	Sends and receives iMessages and SMS
claude-code	Autonomous agents	Delegates coding tasks to Claude Code
codex	Autonomous agents	Delegates coding tasks to OpenAI Codex
hermes-agent	Autonomous agents	Configures and extends the Hermes Agent codebase
opencode	Autonomous agents	Delegates coding and review tasks to OpenCode
computer-use	General	Operates desktop interfaces through visual interaction
architecture-diagram	Creative	Creates architecture and infrastructure diagrams
ascii-art	Creative	Generates and transforms ASCII art
ascii-video	Creative	Converts video and audio into ASCII video
baoyu-infographic	Creative	Produces infographics using reusable layouts and styles
claude-design	Creative	Designs standalone HTML artifacts
comfyui	Creative	Generates images, video, and audio with ComfyUI
design-md	Creative	Authors and validates DESIGN.md specifications
excalidraw	Creative	Creates hand drawn Excalidraw diagrams
humanizer	Creative	Revises text to remove formulaic AI phrasing
manim-video	Creative	Produces mathematical and algorithmic animations
p5js	Creative	Creates interactive p5.js sketches and generative art
popular-web-designs	Creative	Applies established web interface design systems
pretext	Creative	Supports interactive creative browser demonstrations
sketch	Creative	Produces alternative HTML interface mockups
songwriting-and-ai-music	Creative	Supports songwriting and AI music prompting
touchdesigner-mcp	Creative	Controls TouchDesigner through an MCP interface

Figure 5: Monthly Operational Coherence profiles for the Human baseline and all eight Hermes models. Panels report effective window rate, environment tool calls, and monthly net profit.

Table 7: Built in Hermes skills and their functions, continued.
Skill	Category	Description
jupyter-live-kernel	Data science	Performs iterative analysis in a persistent Jupyter kernel
dogfood	General	Conducts exploratory testing of web applications
himalaya	Email	Manages email through the Himalaya command line interface
codebase-inspection	GitHub	Measures codebase size, languages, and composition
github-auth	GitHub	Configures tokens, keys, and command line authentication
github-code-review	GitHub	Reviews pull request diffs and inline comments
github-issues	GitHub	Creates and manages GitHub issues
github-pr-workflow	GitHub	Manages branches, commits, checks, and pull requests
github-repo-management	GitHub	Clones, creates, forks, and maintains repositories
gif-search	Media	Searches and downloads GIF content
heartmula	Media	Generates songs from lyrics and style tags
songsee	Media	Extracts and visualizes audio features
youtube-content	Media	Converts YouTube transcripts into written content
huggingface-hub	MLOps	Searches, downloads, and uploads models and datasets
evaluating-llms-harness	MLOps	Evaluates language models with standard benchmarks
weights-and-biases	MLOps	Tracks experiments, sweeps, and model artifacts
llama-cpp	MLOps	Runs local GGUF model inference
serving-llms-vllm	MLOps	Serves language models with vLLM
audiocraft-audio-generation	MLOps	Generates music and sound with AudioCraft
segment-anything-model	MLOps	Performs prompt based image segmentation
obsidian	Note taking	Reads, searches, creates, and edits Obsidian notes

Figure 6: Monthly Product Sourcing across four representative models. Scores are listing-hour-weighted catalog demand percentiles of active products in each month. Lines and bands show repeat means and standard deviations.

Table 8: Built in Hermes skills and their functions, continued.
Skill	Category	Description
airtable	Productivity	Manages Airtable records and queries
google-workspace	Productivity	Operates Gmail, Calendar, Drive, Docs, and Sheets
maps	Productivity	Provides geocoding, points of interest, routes, and time zones
nano-pdf	Productivity	Edits PDF text and document metadata
notion	Productivity	Manages Notion pages and databases
ocr-and-documents	Productivity	Extracts text from PDFs and scanned documents
petdex	Productivity	Installs and selects animated Hermes mascots
powerpoint	Productivity	Creates and edits presentation decks
teams-meeting-pipeline	Productivity	Operates the Teams meeting summary pipeline
arxiv	Research	Searches arXiv by topic, author, category, or identifier
blogwatcher	Research	Monitors blogs and syndicated feeds
llm-wiki	Research	Builds and queries an interlinked knowledge base
polymarket	Research	Queries prediction markets, prices, and order books
research-paper-writing	Research	Supports machine learning paper development and submission
openhue	Smart home	Controls Philips Hue lights, rooms, and scenes
xurl	Social media	Reads and operates X through its command line interface
hermes-agent-skill-authoring	Software development	Authors and validates Hermes skill packages
node-inspect-debugger	Software development	Debugs Node.js through the inspector protocol
plan	Software development	Produces actionable implementation plans
python-debugpy	Software development	Debugs Python with pdb and debugpy
requesting-code-review	Software development	Performs structured review before integration
simplify-code	Software development	Refines recent code changes with parallel review
spike	Software development	Runs disposable experiments before implementation
systematic-debugging	Software development	Applies a structured root cause debugging process
test-driven-development	Software development	Applies test driven development workflows
yuanbao	General	Operates Yuanbao groups and member queries

Figure 11: Composition and calibrated distributions of the filtered data. Panel (a) reports the numbers of Product Records and unique supplier IDs within each category. Panel (b) shows procurement price distributions within each category. Panel (c) shows the joint distribution of Downstream Order Outcome probability and Upstream Supplier Event intensity.

Table 19: Product fields and their visibility to the merchant agent. Catalog results also include the public supplier fields in Table 20.
Product field	Access	Meaning
product_id	Visible	Stable identifier for a Product in the Product Catalog
name	Visible	Marketplace product title used for retrieval and comparison
category	Visible	One of the ten normalized first level product categories
quantity	Visible	Current effective supplier inventory after replenishment
price	Visible	Current procurement price offered by the supplier
historical_avg_rating	Visible	Historical product rating obtained from the source platform
logistics_hours	Visible	Baseline transit time from supplier dispatch to delivery
is_listed_by_supplier	Visible	Current procurement availability, exposed as supplier_available
ref_price	Hidden	Reference price used in the price response term of the demand model
base_price	Hidden	Supplier price restored after a temporary Price Change ends
cancel_rate	Hidden	Product level probability used to sample Cancellation
refund_rate	Hidden	Product level probability used to sample Return and Refund
only_refund_rate	Hidden	Product level probability used to sample Returnless Refund
bad_review_rate	Hidden	Product level probability used to sample Bad Review
max_quantity	Hidden	Inventory capacity used by the supplier replenishment process
hourly_increment	Hidden	Hourly supplier inventory replenishment amount
elasticity	Hidden	Product specific price elasticity used by the demand model
market_curve	Hidden	Real-world product level demand history over 365 days
quantity_updated_t	Hidden	Internal timestamp used for lazy inventory replenishment
price_recover_t	Hidden	Prescheduled end time of an active Price Change
delist_recover_t	Hidden	Prescheduled end time of an active Product Delisting

Figure 12: Temporal demand patterns in the filtered data. The top panel presents aggregate daily demand and its seven day mean. The bottom panels show normalized demand histories for representative red envelope, electric fan, and hot water bag Product Records.

Table 20: Supplier fields and their visibility to the merchant agent. Supplier trust attributes are constant across Products sharing the same supplier_id, while event hazards are calibrated at the Product level.
Supplier field	Access	Meaning
supplier_id	Visible	Stable supplier identifier
supplier_name	Visible	Public supplier name
shop_rating	Visible	Public supplier rating shared by all Products from the supplier
return_buyer_rate	Visible	Public repeat buyer rate returned by the supplier profile
supplier_age_years	Visible	Public supplier tenure in years
product_count	Visible	Number of currently available Products from the supplier
supplier_ship_hours	Visible	Current dispatch time for a Product from this supplier
base_ship_hours	Hidden	Dispatch time restored after a Shipment Delay ends
timeout_rate	Hidden	Product level hazard for Shipment Delay
price_change_rate	Hidden	Product level hazard for Price Change
supplier_delist_rate	Hidden	Product level hazard for Product Delisting
timeout_active	Hidden	Internal indicator of an active Shipment Delay
timeout_recover_t	Hidden	Prescheduled end time of an active Shipment Delay

Figure 13: Monthly Operational Coherence profiles for the Human baseline and each of the eight Hermes models. Panels (a), (b), (c), and (d) report effective window rate, environment tool calls, month end active listings, and monthly net profit.

Table 21: Order fields and their visibility to the merchant agent. Some visible lifecycle fields remain empty until realization, while presampled future outcomes and internal schedules remain hidden.
Order field	Access	Meaning
order_id	Visible	Stable identifier for an individual customer order
product_id, product_name	Visible	Product identity associated with the order
supplier_id, supplier_name	Visible	Supplier identity associated with the order
order_time	Visible	Calendar and simulation time at which the order was placed
current_status	Visible	Latest realized lifecycle state
status_age_hours	Visible	Elapsed time since the latest realized status transition
expected_delivery_time	Visible	Current delivery estimate computed from realized timing information
delivered_time	Visible	Merchant facing delivery timestamp populated after delivery
late_time	Visible	Merchant facing timestamp populated only after Late Shipment is realized
sale_price	Visible	Merchant selling price recorded when the order was created
purchase_price	Visible	Procurement price recorded when the order was created
supplier_ship_hours	Visible	Supplier dispatch duration recorded for the order
supplier_logistics_hours	Visible	Baseline post dispatch logistics duration
actual_logistics_hours	Visible	Realized transit duration populated after delivery
realized_revenue	Visible	Revenue credited from outcomes realized so far
realized_cost	Visible	Procurement cost realized so far
total_penalty	Visible	Sum of penalties already applied to the order
net_profit	Visible	Realized revenue minus realized cost and total penalty
profit_finalized	Visible	Indicator that no further profit component remains unresolved
status_log	Visible	Realized sequence of lifecycle states and their timestamps
preset_anomaly	Hidden	Presampled future outcome among normal fulfillment and four customer abnormalities
preset_anomaly_t	Hidden	Internal realization time of the presampled abnormal outcome
settlement_delay_steps	Hidden	Presampled delay from delivery to final settlement
purchase_t, shipped_t, delivered_t, settled_t	Hidden	Raw internal transition times, with only realized merchant facing views exposed

Figure 14: Monthly Operational Coherence profiles for the Human baseline and each of the eight ReAct models. Panels (a), (b), (c), and (d) report effective window rate, environment tool calls, month end active listings, and monthly net profit.

研究结果

表现最好的LLM配置(Hermes框架下的Qwen3.7-Max)最终净资产也只达到人类参与者平均水平的27.3%。
在8个模型的平均水平上,Hermes框架比ReAct框架的最终净资产高53.3%、GMV高71.5%、订单量多71.2%,8个模型中有7个在Hermes下表现更好(仅Kimi K2.6例外,低4.1%)。
人类参与者的持续窗口率(SWR)达到100%,而LLM配置在ReAct下为10.6%到99.4%,在Hermes下为17.8%到66.1%,显示活动量随时间明显衰减。
部分模型在没有依据的情况下固守错误策略:一次Hermes框架下的Claude Opus 4.8运行中,智能体错误地认为减少上架商品能让流量集中,导致活跃商品从47个减少到3个;一次Hermes框架下的Kimi K2.6运行在第104天判定店铺无法挽救后,在剩余523个决策窗口中有355个未采取任何行动。
人类参与者随着资金增加逐步扩大采购价格区间,从前三个月的43.4至53.1元人民币扩大到后三个月的58.7至90.8元人民币,而GLM-5.2、DeepSeek-V4-Flash和Kimi K2.6的定价区间则相对停滞不变。

Figure 15: Daily net asset curves for all eight models under ReAct over 365 simulated days.

可应用场景

可作为评测框架,用于检验需要长期自主管理库存、定价、现金流的智能体在运营中是否会活动衰减或目标漂移。
可用于比较不同LLM与智能体框架(仅工具调用 vs 附带记忆/技能管理)在长期业务表现上的差异。
可作为诊断方法,检验智能体能否将延迟反馈(退货、退款、差评)追溯到此前的决策并加以修正。

Figure 16: Daily net asset curves for all eight models under Hermes over 365 simulated days.

局限与待验证事项

该环境是基于1688平台数据构建的模拟系统,与真实网店经营在监管、竞争、客户行为等方面仍存在差异。
结果基于每个配置三次重复运行,部分配置(如Hermes下的Qwen3.7-Max)波动很大(变异系数达55.1%),解读结果时需考虑这种不稳定性。
人类基线仅有三名无电商经营经验的参与者,因此'达到人类27.3%'这一数字不宜直接推广为专业卖家的表现基准。
论文中提到的GPT-5.6、Claude Opus 4.8、Qwen3.7系列等模型名称可能与公开已知版本不完全对应,读者应关注基准设计本身而非将其视为对当前最新模型的权威排名。
关于Hermes附加能力(代码执行、技能创建)为何只对部分模型有效,论文仅通过案例观察进行讨论,尚缺乏系统性的因果分析。

为什么重要

这项研究用具体数字证实了一个普遍担忧:LLM智能体在短任务上表现不错,但在长达数月的自主经营任务中容易失去方向。对于正在设计需要长期自主运行的库存管理、定价决策等自动化系统的人来说,这提前指出了失败可能出现的地方——活动衰减、过早放弃、以及证据积累后仍不修正的僵化策略。

本文术语

长期连贯性(Long-Term Coherence) · 在长时间跨度中持续保持有目的的行为,并随着证据积累调整决策的能力
部分可观测马尔可夫决策过程(POMDP) · 智能体只能看到部分真实状态、必须基于不完整信息做决策的建模框架
持续窗口率(Sustained Window Rate, SWR) · 在任意连续30天的滚动周期内,至少发起一次环境工具调用的决策窗口所占的最低比例
Hermes / ReAct · ReAct是仅用26种工具的最简控制器,Hermes在此基础上加入了代码执行、记忆和技能管理等功能
上游供应商事件 / 下游订单结果 · 供应商端很快显现的事件(涨价、下架等)与订单端延迟显现的结果(退货、退款、差评等)

论文原文摘要（英文）

Large language model agents are increasingly evaluated as autonomous tool users, yet most benchmarks focus on bounded tasks with immediate success criteria. Real-world deployments often require Long-Term Coherence, the capacity to preserve purposeful behavior across extended horizons while adapting decisions to accumulated evidence. Evaluating this capacity requires a persistent environment in which actions constrain future choices, feedback arrives at heterogeneous delays, and incoherent behavior produces measurable cumulative effects. Seller-side e-commerce provides a suitable setting for this evaluation through recurrent and interdependent decisions over Product Sourcing, Listing and Pricing Control, Cash-Flow Management, and Mixed-Latency Feedback Adaptation. We introduce MerchantBench, a 365-day order-level simulation grounded in 98,843 real e-commerce product records and equipped with 26 tools for agent interaction. MerchantBench couples promptly observable Upstream Supplier Events with delayed Downstream Order Outcomes, requiring agents to follow individual order lifecycles and revisit earlier decisions. We evaluate eight LLMs under two agent frameworks in 48 runs, each spanning 365 simulated days. Our results reveal a substantial gap between even the latest LLMs and human participants, with the best LLM configuration attaining only 27.3\% of the mean final net assets achieved by human participants.

作者 · Qiming Shi

在 arXiv 阅读

METAL LAB 最新报道

图片来源： Qiming Shi et al., arXiv:2607.28956, arxiv-nonexclusive